Best Heavy Putters 2022

Finding consistency on the green is one of the easiest ways to quickly improve your scorecard.

Heavy putters help golfers form the habit of a simple and consistent putting stroke. The increased weight gives the player a better feel for the club and creates greater distance control on putts.

Because of these benefits, heavy putters have experienced a boom in popularity in recent years. 

This increase in demand has led to an influx of new models in the heavy putter market, all ranging in quality, weight, and effectiveness. 

Choosing the wrong model can have a negative effect on your putting, so it’s important to pick the right one for your stroke.

Fortunately, our team tested 20 of the top heavy putters on the market today to help you make an informed choice that will help your game. 

In a rush to find the perfect heavy putter? Check out our top performers list below.

If you’re looking for in-depth analysis, keep scrolling for our complete guide to the heavy putter market.

Best Heavy Putters 2022

Golfible Picks:

Editor’s Choice: Ping Harwood Mallet Putter (click to see)
Most Forgiving Heavy Putter: Taylormade Spider GT Putter

Best Cheap Heavy Putter: Odyssey White Hot Pro (click to see)

Best Heavy Putter For Feel: Odyssey Stroke Lab Tuttle Putter (click to see)

Best Heavy Putter For Women: Pinemeadow Golf Women’s PGX Putter (click to see)
Best Arm Lock Heavy Putter (Anchor Ban Alternative): Odyssey 2-Ball Ten Arm Lock Tour Lined Putter (click to see)

Best Premium Priced Heavy Putter: Scotty Cameron Phantom (click to see)


Putter NamePing Harwood Mallet PutterTaylormade Spider GTOdyssey White Hot ProOdyssey Stroke Lab TuttlePinemeadow Golf Women’s PGXOdyssey 2-Ball Ten Arm Lock Tour LinedScotty Cameron Phantom
Our Rating9.8/10
Editor’s Choice
9.5/10
Most Forgiving Heavy Putter
8.7/10
Best Cheap Heavy Putter
9.1/10
Best Heavy Putter For Feel
9.0/10
Best Heavy Putter For Women
9.1/10
Best Arm Lock Heavy Putter
9.5/10
Best Premium Priced Heavy Putter
PricingJump To Pricing SectionJump To Pricing SectionJump To Pricing SectionJump To Pricing SectionJump To Pricing SectionJump To Pricing SectionJump To Pricing Section
Putter TypeMalletProgressive MalletBladeMalletMalletMalletProgressive Mallet
HoselFlow NeckShort Slant/Single BendCrank HoselDouble BendNo HoselNo HoselLow Single Bend
Weight DistributionFace BalancedToe HangToe HangFace BalancedFace BalancedFace BalancedFace Balanced
Head Weight385g350g (35″ length), 365g (33″ and 34″ lengths)350g365g380g385g370g (33″ length), 360g (34″ length), 350g (35″ length)
AlignmentThree Sight LinesTrue Path With SightlineSingle SightlineTriple Sight LinesTriples Sight Lines2-Ball AlignmentSingle Sightline
GripPing Midsize PP60 GripTM Pistol GTR 1.0 Black/RedOdyssey DFX GripOdyssey OversizedPinemeadow SpiderOdyssey Arm LockPistolero Plus
Standard Length33″-35″33″-35″33″-35″35″33″40″, 42″33″-35″
Loft 3 degrees3 degrees3 degrees3 degrees3 degrees7 degrees3.5 degrees
Lie Angle20 degrees70 degrees70 degrees70 degrees70 degrees72 degrees70 degrees
Read ReviewJump To Ping Harwood Mallet ReviewJump To Taylormade Spider GT ReviewJump To Odyssey White Hot Pro ReviewJump To Odyssey Stroke Lab Tuttle ReviewJump To Pinemeadow Golf Women’s PGX ReviewJump To Odyssey 2-Ball Ten Arm Lock Tour Lined ReviewJump To Scotty Cameron Phantom Review

Ping Harwood Putter

Editor’s Choice

Rating: 9.8 /10

Pros

  • Available in 33 to 36 inches when bought stock.
  • Equipped with Ping’s iconic pistol grip (PP60) that is highly rated in the golf community.
  • Extremely versatile since it can be used by golfers with different putting strokes.

Cons

  • Due to the model being constructed from expensive materials, the price point of the putter is much costlier compared to other Ping makes such as the Anser series.
  • The Harwood is only available in one color (black with hints of white and red).

The Ping Harwood putter is Ping’s high-end putter model available to the public and our editor’s choice at Golfible. This putter is a fantastic fit for players who employ slightly arcing putting strokes and slower tempos. 

When testing the putter, we found it comparable to the Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X model. The weight and quality of both putters felt extremely similar. 

Ping created the putter to be extremely forgiving with a multi-material build that includes a dual-durometer insert. This gives the club a more responsive feel that helps golfers with distance control on the greens. 

The company also added a front layer of Pebax polymer that helps create a bounce off of the front of the face during contact. This aids in sinking shorter putts. The grooves on the face of the club were made shallower to promote a more consistent roll. 

The Harwood is made from a variety of quality materials such as 17-4 stainless steel, aluminum, and tungsten. Ping increased the moment of inertia and also updated the center of gravity. This allows players to still achieve desirable results when not striking the putt in the center of the sweet spot. 

The putter can be used for two different stroke styles (slight arc or straight back and straight through) and features three white lines to help with alignment. 

This club is good for any level of golfer. Low-handicappers and high use both types of putting strokes.


Taylormade Spider GT Putter

Most forgiving heavy putter

Rating: 9.5 /10

Pros

  • The clubhead will remain shiny and is extremely durable thanks to TaylorMade’s anodized aluminum finish. This lasts longer than paint and physical vapor deposition finishes.
  • Many users said that it was more stable than other high-end putters they’ve used before.
  • The perimeter weighting makes it more forgiving than many other putters on the market.

Cons

  • Not available in 36 inches when purchased stock.
  • Not everyone will be a fan of the shiny metallic look.

The TaylorMade Spider GT is our selection for the most forgiving heavy putter. It’s the first Spider model to showcase an open-frame multi-material build. 

The model has two steel “side wings” that weigh 90 grams each. It is made from 304 stainless steel. The putter’s total weight is 82% on the perimeter which allows for solid strokes on hits far from the sweet spot. When testing it, we noticed that the club stayed very stable and it was easy to maintain the same tempo on each putting stroke. 

There are multiple models of this putter with different weights. The black silver bend weighs 350 grams at 35 inches as well as the red silver bend. The silver single bend is heavier at 365 grams at all lengths (33-35 inches). The short-slanted model is 365 grams at 33 and 34 inches but 350 grams at 35 inches. Switching to a 35-inch, 350 gram version will cause you to lose the “heavy putter feel”.

Since the Spider GT is so forgiving, it’s extremely useful for high-handicappers, not just low and mid. Beginners often have trouble gathering the correct green speeds on lag puts. The GT helps a lot in that regard.

TaylorMade’s pure roll technology is an upgrade from the brand’s tour-proven inserts. The insert is designed with a strong TPU urethane and has silver aluminum bars at 45 degree angles which promote a consistent roll and helps maintain speeds when lag putting. Lag putting is trying to keep the ball within a close distance to the hole so you can easily tap it in.

The company makes both short slant and single bend styles of putters. Short slant putters are ideal for golfers with an arced stroke (their motion goes inside, square and then inside). 
Single bend putters are better for golfers who like going straight back and straight through.


Odyssey White Hot Pro

Best cheap heavy putter

Rating: 8.7 /10

Odyssey White Hot Pro
usa suppliers

uSA Suppliers (some deliver to Canada)

Canada Suppliers

Pros

  • Quality at a great price
  • Optimized weighting
  • Laser milling on face allows for consistency
  • Impressive feel
  • Great alignment aids
  • Good balance
  • Tour-proven

Cons

  • Somewhat confusing range of options to choose from
  • The design might take some time to get used to

Despite the technology and development that has gone into this popular heavy putter, it is remarkably affordable. Even though we have rated this as our best cheap heavy putter it is a favorite with many pros and that says a lot about the quality and effectiveness of the design.

The “White hot” insert is where the name comes from and it is one of the leading features of the putter. It aids in performance, feel, and sound. Feel is critical and especially important on putters. Most agree that Callaway has done a great job in this regard. 

The insert features laser milling which delivers accuracy and consistency. The weight distribution between the toe and heel allows for more forgiveness. If you miss the putter’s sweet spot you can still expect a reasonable result.

The alignment aids are highly effective and should help with accuracy. The putter has a good sound and feel and this responsiveness should be appreciated by most players.

There are a number of options to choose from and some might find the array a bit bewildering. Take the time to consider your personal putting style and preference.


Odyssey Stroke Lab Tuttle Putter

Best Heavy Putter For Feel

Rating: 9.1 /10

Pros

  • Great feel
  • Good topspin
  • Consistent performance
  • Impressive distance control
  • Appealing feel
  • Effective alignment aids
  • Optimized shaft for increased control

Cons

  • On the expensive side
  • More conservative golfers might not like the look

This was an easy pick for our Editor’s choice. The Odyssey Stroke Lab Versa from  Callaway stands out as one of the most popular options available and is loved by a great many golfers. While Callaway is probably most famous for its drivers they are becoming a leading choice for other clubs, particularly putters.

The weight distribution is one of the outstanding features of this putter. Much research and development went into optimizing the weight of the Odyssey Stroke Lab Versa. Part of the innovation was a steel and graphite shaft that is tip-heavy. This gave Callaway around 40 grams to play with in other areas for beneficial weighting.

Speaking of the shaft, it is relatively stiff with a lower torque compared to your average putter. This allows for better control of the heavy head of the putter.  The result of the design and weighting allows for better control and good consistency for most players.

Another technology that Callaway is known for is the face micro hinges. These deliver a decent topspin and help with distance control. The alignment aids are prominent and well designed and those that want them are sure to appreciate them.


Pinemeadow Golf Women’s PGX Putter

Best heavy putter for women

Rating: 9.0 /10

Pinemeadow Golf Women’s PGX Putter
usa suppliers

uSA Suppliers (some deliver to Canada)

Canada Suppliers

uK Suppliers

Pros

  • Fantastic price
  • Impressive looks
  • Good contrast for easy alignment
  • “Tour weighted” so ideal for most fast greens
  • Comes with a headcover

Cons

  • Not the greatest sound and feedback
  • The finish is not highly durable

Pinemeadow is arguably one of the most underrated golf equipment manufacturers. They have been around for a while and make quality clubs at affordable prices. For ladies looking for a good heavy putter, this is an appealing option.

It is a popular choice that is highly rated by the vast majority of users.

The crisp white finish appeals to most and allows for easy and accurate alignment. It is “tour weighted”  at 380 grams making it ideal for faster greens.

The weighted mallet design should allow for a smooth roll that is consistent and accurate. Most ladies will attest to the fact that it is an accurate putter with good control.

The putter comes with a headcover to protect it. It will appeal to beginners as well as more advanced lady golfers. Pinemeadow offers a range of shaft lengths so that you can select the ideal length for your needs.

The price is fantastically low but even if you are not on a tight budget it is still a great option to consider.


Odyssey 2-Ball Ten Arm Lock Tour Lined Putter

Best arm lock heavy putter (anchor ban alternative)

Rating: 9.1 /10

Pros

  • Available in both 40 and 42 inch options.
  • Made from durable materials making it resistant to scratches.
  • The arm lock style lets golfers try a new putting method if they’ve had trouble in the past.

Cons

  • Some users complained that the stock grip was too thin and showed signs of wear quickly.
  • The older models of the 2-ball didn’t have a line going through the balls, this might not appeal to everyone.

The Odyssey 2-ball Ten Arm Lock Tour Lined Putter is a legal putter to use in competitive play. The 2-ball design has continued to be made by the company since its release in 2001.

Many players love the design and believe the alignment aid (2 white balls with a line in the middle straight through them) is one of the best available. 

The putter has an elongated shaft as well as 7 degrees of loft which allows players to lean the upper part of the shaft against their left arm without anchoring it against their body (illegal).

The shape of the club head was specifically designed to improve the moment of inertia compared to prior models. This helps players put a consistent stroke on their putts. 

Odyssey’s Tour Lined Putter is meant for golfers who previously used anchor putters. If you have a traditional putting style, and it’s working for you, it’s probably not worth going from a 33-35 inch putter to a 40-inch model.

When put to the test, we found that the putter allowed us to quickly learn how hard or soft to hit it and maintain a comfortable speed on lag puts. It’s also easy to line up the alignment aid towards the center of the cup.

The putter comes with an adjustable weighting feature so golfers can put it at a weight they’re comfortable playing. The make comes with two 15-gram weight screws.


Scotty Cameron Phantom X

Best premium priced heavy putter

Rating: 9.5 /10

Pros

  • Multiple style options
  • Color combinations allow for a bold alignment aid
  • High MOI
  • Comfortable grip

Cons

  • The modern design might not appeal to more traditional golfers
  • Relatively expensive

Again, this is one of the lesser-known putters but if you are looking for a heavy putter it is worth considering. It offers a range of head styles depending on your needs and preference.

They are finished in a sleek black aluminum and there are a number of head designs to choose form. The choice means that there is a look to suit most preferences although some might find the look a bit too modern.

The color combination allows for a distinctive alignment aid that most will appreciate.

The putter has a thick and comfortable grip which should allow for greater control.

There is not a great deal of feedback on the  Scotty Cameron putter but what there is fairly positive. Most golfers report good control and consistency.

Are heavier putters better?

Most golfers have experienced the dreaded yips from time to time. While it is generally an anxiety issue it can have a physical cause.

Whatever the reason, poor putting can blow your entire game. Having a putter that gives you confidence will make all the difference. Many people find that a heavier putter is the solution.

We look at the specifics to see if it is indeed a viable answer. Like so many aspects of golf, there is no definitive answer. A lot will depend on your putting style, your experience and confidence level on the green, your strength and personal preference.

The perfect stroke for putting is a simple backwards and then forwards pendulum-like motion that remains straight throughout. Quite obviously, you need to read the green and be well aligned. This simple motion can be difficult for many to do correctly every time.

Many believe that a heavy putter will reduce wrist action and give you greater control of the stroke. Manufacturers spend vast amounts of money on sophisticated research and development.

The weight of the average utter on the market has steadily increased over the last ten years or so. They must have a good reason for doing that.

Older players that have lost a bit of muscle strength might benefit greatly from this. As their grip and arm strength decreases, a heavier putter will allow for the shoulders to do most of the work.

Most argue that a heavy putter will reduce the chance of the head twisting or wobbling during the stroke. This will naturally lead to more accurate shots and improved consistency.  


Heavy vs Light putter

Benefits of a Heavy Putter

  • Reduces wrist action
  • Makes greater use of shoulder muscles
  • Allows for a more natural pendulum motion
  • Aids in keeping the stroke in a straight line
  • Reduces the risk of the head twisting
  • Lets you play a slower stroke which should add to control
  • Generally gives better control and consistency
  • Ideal on a fast green

Drawbacks of a Heavy Putter

  • It might take some time to get used to
  • More suitable for shorter putts than long shots
  • Not the best option on slower greens

Benefits of Light Putter

  • Generally better for longer putts
  • Is the style of putter most players are familiar with
  • Better on a slow green

Drawbacks of Light Putter

  • Can cause wrist action
  • Greater risk of the heat twisting or turning during the stroke

While the USGA’s rules are very strict when it comes to golf equipment, they are not too concerned over the weight of the putter. That might change in the future but for now, there is no weight limit.

The only weight restrictions that currently apply, and this is true for all clubs, is that those with an adjustable weight cannot be changed during a round.

There are a couple of putters with adjustable weights so be sure to remember this rule for competition play.

Is a heavier putter better for fast greens?

A heavier putter will allow for a short back stroke for a slower stroke with more control and this makes them a great option on fast greens. Fast greens are more popular in many areas these days so it is all the more reason to consider a heavy putter.

Fast greens can be daunting and you want all the help you can get to give you the confidence needed.

Again, much will depend on your putting stroke and your personal preference. The above might not hold true for all golfers. What is important is that your putter has good feel and you feel confident when using it.

What does a heavy putter grip do?

Weight in a putter is not just about the weight of the head. The grip is also extremely important. The weight of the grip is also heavier on these putters and it has the same benefits.  It should reduce wrist action and help you achieve a smooth pendulum-like putting stroke. 

When using these putters you would be able to grip them more loosely than you would with a light putter. This could help improve the all-important aspect of feel when putting. It might, however, take a while to get used to.

How do I decide if a heavy putter is right for me?

There a number of schools of thought and what works for one golfer might not necessarily work for you. The only way to know for sure is to try out a few heavy putters and see how it goes. You would have to do some serious analysis and not simply hit a few balls at the pro shop.

The other option is to consider professional fitting. They will analyze your swing and style, often with the aid of advanced technology. This, combined with their knowledge and experience should allow them to recommend the best option for your specific needs.

If you do make the change it will require some practice as a heavy putter performs quite differently to a light putter that you might have been using for many years. Take the time to get to know your heavy putter if you invest in one.

Final thoughts

The best putter for you is the one that feels comfortable and works for you. A heavier putter might well be the answer and they are worth checking out. There are a number of potential benefits and they could well help you shave a few points off your game.

FAQ

Which putters are the heaviest?

The best heavier putters’ options in the market are Odyssey Golf, TaylorMade Spider Tour Black, and Men’s Pinemeadow.The head of these putters are slightly higher than the conventional golf club’s putter, so they tend to swing smoothly.

How Much Does A Heavy Putter Weigh?

While a regular putter normally weighs 330 to 350 grams a heavy putter is significantly more. They average from 365 to 400 grams.

Photo of author

Author

Charl is a full-time writer who has been with Golfible since 2019. He is an avid golfer and tech enthusiast. When not writing, he tries to squeeze in a round of golf or escape to the mountains. Learn more about the Golfible team on our About Us page.

Leave a Comment