Best Scotty Cameron Putters (In-Depth 2024 Review)

Scotty Cameron putters are known by many as the gold standard of all putters. 

Choosing the correct Scotty Cameron model can help you save several strokes per round by rolling the ball consistently on the greens.

Purchasing a Scotty Cameron putter is an investment in your game.

After all, these putters are used by the top professionals on tour and since they’re the best money can buy, they also boast a hefty price tag. 

Not all Scotty Cameron putters will fit every golfer’s game, though, and it’s important to determine which one is right for you out of the many models on the market today.

To help you make the best choice, our team has tested 15 of the latest Scotty Cameron putters and determined which ones are best for your golf game.

Looking for a quick chart of our favorites?

Our top choices are listed first with some quick bullet points. If you want the full rundown, all the details on our Scotty Cameron putter review are listed further down the page.

Best Scotty Cameron Putters

Golfible Picks:

Top Pick – Blade Putter: Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 (click to see)

Top Pick Mallet Putter for Mid to Low Handicappers: Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X7 (click to see)

Runner Up Mallet Putter for Mid to Low Handicappers: Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X9 (click to see)

Most Forgiving and Best for High Handicappers: Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X11 (click to see)

Scotty Cameron Putters Specification Table Comparison

Putter NameScotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X7Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X9Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X11
Our Rating9.5/10
Top Pick – Blade Putter
9.2/10
Top Mallet Putter For Mid to Low Handicappers
9.2/10
Runner Up Mallet Putter for Mid to Low Handicappers
9.4/10
Most Forgiving and Best for High Handicappers
PricingJump To Pricing SectionJump To Pricing SectionJump To Pricing SectionJump To Pricing Section
Putter TypeBladeMalletMalletMid-Mallet
HoselPlumbers NeckMid Single BendMid Single BendMid Single Bend
Weight DistributionMedium Toe FlowNear-Face BalancedNear-Face BalancedFace Balanced
Head Weight2 x 40g(33″ length),
2 x 35g(34″ length),
2 x 30g (35″ length)
2 x 20g (33″ length)
2 x 15g (34″ length) 2 x 10g (35″ length)
2 x 20g (33″ length)
2 x 15g (34″ length)
2 x 10g (35″ length)
2 x 20g (33″ length),
2 x 15g (34″ length),
2 x 10g (35″ length)
GripPistolini PlusPistolero PlusPistolero PlusPistolero Plus
Standard Length33″, 34″, 35″33″, 34″, 35″33″, 34″, 35″33″, 34″, 35″
Loft 3.5⁰3.5⁰3.5⁰3.5⁰
Lie Angle70⁰70⁰70⁰70⁰
Read ReviewJump To Scotty Cameron Newport 2 ReviewJump To Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X7 ReviewJump To Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X9 ReviewJump To Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X11 Review

Scotty Cameron special Select Newport 2

Top Pick – Blade Putter

Rating: 9.5 /10

Pros

  • Better sight lines than previous models
  • Perfect weight for big sweet spot

Cons

  • Less forgiving for beginners

As soon as they were released, our team set out to find the best putter for every golfer from the newest line of the iconic Scotty Cameron brand.

While Scotty Cameron released several putters with different head shapes and sizes, the iconic Special Select Newport 2 putter was our tester’s clear favorite blade putter of the bunch.

If you’re looking for a blade-style putter, don’t mind paying a premium and want the absolute best option on the market, the Scotty Cameron’s Newport 2 is the only choice.

It might be the most iconic putter of all time, but the Newport 2 received a few small updates in its latest release that enhanced the performance of this classic design.

The neck of the putter shaft has been altered slightly and it’s a little further back on the Newport 2, which opens up your sight lines and allows for perfect alignment, giving you confidence as soon as you stand over the ball.

Another innovation in this model is the unique weighting model that balances the putter perfectly and allows for a consistent and pure stroke.

The Newport 2 uses heavy weights in the sole of the club to make it more stable and create a big sweet spot, so each putt is hit solidly and you have a better chance at consistency on the greens.

Aside from the tech innovations in this putter, you’re getting a statement piece for your golf bag. The Newport design is responsible for over 100 wins on the PGA tour and was Tiger Woods’ putter of choice for the majority of his career.

What we love about the Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 Putter

  • Easy Alignment: With the improved shaft position and the Newport’s classic design, lining putts up comes naturally.
  • Perfect Weighting: The weight in the bottom of the club is obvious from the time you pick it up. It feels great to swing and this weight helps you stay on the same plane for every putting stroke.

Drawbacks of the Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 Putter

Forgiveness: While the Newport 2 is one of the top of the line putters on the market,much like blade-style irons it’s not designed for beginners. If you’re a higher handicap player, you will likely want to select a more forgiving model.

You can’t go wrong with the latest iteration of the iconic Newport 2. This is one of the best putters on the market today and it’s hard to argue with its performance on the course.


Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X7

Top Pick Mallet Putter for Mid to Low Handicappers

Rating: 9.2 /10

Pros

  • Alignment aids inspire confidence
  • Perfectly balanced stable stroke

Cons

  • Single bend shaft not appealing for all golfers

We tested the new Scotty Cameron putters to make a list of the best fits for golfers with different style preferences and handicaps. Our testers agreed the best mallet putter for mid to low handicappers was easily the Phantom X7.

If you are considering a Scotty Cameron mallet-style putter and want to push your handicap closer to single digits or even zero, the Phantom X7 is the perfect choice.

Summed up, this is the premier mallet-style putter on the market today.

So, what sets the Phantom X7 apart from other putters in the Scotty Cameron line?

For starters, this putter is perfectly balanced with long, angled wings behind the face that increase stability on every putt. When the lie is fit perfectly to the golfer, the putter provides an easy, repeatable stroke so pushing putts left or right is much less likely.

Aside from the tech, you get top-of-the line design and materials from this design. The milled stainless steel face and aluminum sole help with alignment and this will give you confidence every time you stand over the ball.

The wings behind the face combined with the alignment line on top of the head allow you to easily visualize the ball’s path directly to the cup.

What we love about the Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X7

  • Confidence-Inspiring Alignment Tools: This putter lets you see the line of the ball before you make your shot. Putting is largely mental, and the lines of this putter are perfect for making sure you have the perfect aim before making your putt.
  • Perfect Balance – The wings on this club help with alignment, of course, but their added weight to the outside edges of the club behind the face leads to an easy and natural putting motion.

Drawbacks of the Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X7

Mid-Bend Shaft: The only potential drawback of a putter the caliber of the Phantom X7 is a matter of personal preference. The shaft bends near the club face, creating an angle perfectly aligned with the shaft and face. While many golfers love this design, some of our testers preferred a more traditional shaft.

If you want the best putter on the market today and prefer a mallet-style model then the Phantom X7 should be your choice.


Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X9

Runner Up Mallet Putter for Mid to Low Handicappers

Rating: 9.2 /10

Pros

  • Customizable sole weights
  • High quality materials and finishes

Cons

  • No sight line on the top of the club head

Scotty Cameron’s new models are the latest in a long line of high-performing putters, and we set out to find the best ones for different handicaps and playing styles.

In a close contest, the Phantom X9 was named as our runner up for mid to low handicap players who prefer mallet-style putters.

The Phantom X9 brings the same style and prestige that comes with other Scotty Cameron models, and if you are a skilled golfer looking for one of the top models on the market today then the X9 is a great choice.

If you like the X9’s styling then it’s a quality putter to take strokes off your card quickly.

Like all Scotty Cameron putters, the X9 is made of high quality materials and that fact is obvious as soon as you pick it up. The club itself is made from airplane-grade aluminum on the sole and milled stainless steel on the face. The result is a perfectly balanced putter that delivers a confident stroke.

The X9 features a few elements that will appeal to low-handicappers like the mid-bend shaft and the sight line between the wings on the back of the club to help with alignment. The X9 also features weights in the sole of the putter, so you can make sure the weight of the club is perfect for your putting stroke.

The result of this technology is a putter that produces consistent strokes and allows you to feel confident each time you’re on the green.

What we love about the Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X9

  • Customizable: The X9 is one of a few new Scotty Cameron models with customizable weights in the sole. Putting is all about feel, so the choice to change the putter to be lighter or heavier depending on the best feel for you is a big plus.
  • Unique Shape: The back of the X9 forms a solid shape unlike some of the other “hollow” mallet putters in the Phantom line. Our testers liked the solid feel of this putter and it inspires confidence at approach.

Drawbacks of the Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X9

Alignment Lines: While the X9 does feature an alignment line, many of our testers preferred the sight lines on the X7 that both outline the ball and provide a midpoint to line up with.

The X9 was our runner-up choice for the best new mallet putter in the Phantom line. It’s a great choice, especially if the style matches up with your personal preference. 


Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X11

Most Forgiving and Best for High Handicappers

Rating: 9.4 /10

Pros

  • Clear visual alignment tools
  • Mid-bend shaft to keep the face from turning

Cons

  • Some testers didn’t like the size of the club head

For players with a higher handicap who are looking for a putter to provide the most forgiveness on the greens, the Phantom X11 was our favorite new Scotty Cameron putter,

If you’re a beginner or are struggling to find a consistent stroke on the greens, the Phantom X11 is the putter you’re looking for to help shave strokes off your card on every round.

Put simply: you’ll feel confident putting anywhere with this putter designed for maximum ease of use.

So, what makes the Phantom X11 best for beginners?

Putting effectively has a lot to do with how confident you are in your putting line, and the X11 is designed with visual styling that allows you to get a clear read on each putt. Its got darker lines behind the club face that naturally draw a line from your ball to the cup.

Line it up, move your arms straight back and forward, and watch the ball go in the hole. It’s that simple with the X11.

One of the things that helps beginners is the X11’s mid-bend shape that keeps the club face as straight as possible. Many high handicappers allow the club to turn when they’re putting, which forces the ball off line. The X11 minimizes that risk.

What we love about the Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X11

  • Easy Alignment: Rather than using painted lines or guides, the X11’s design itself is your visual cue. Line the dark part of the club up with the hole and let it rip.
  • Mid-Bend Shaft: This putter’s shaft takes full advantage of its mallet style by keeping the club head straight through your putting stroke.

Drawbacks of the Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X11

Club Head Size: While it’s not a deal to some golfers, a few of our testers said the club head was just too big for their tastes. It might take some getting used to if you’re coming from a smaller putter.

For higher handicap golfers looking for the most forgiving putter, the X11 is the clear favorite in the Scotty Cameron line because it’s designed to get the ball rolling exactly where you want it to go.


Why Is Scotty Cameron Designs Considered High Quality?

Scotty Cameron Putters are considered to be such high quality because they are designed with such precision and detail. They have been used by professionals for over 25 years. The putters are customizable. 

Golfers are recorded when putting and Scotty Cameron designs a putter right for their stroke and style. The soft trailing edge on his putters are one of the many reasons so many people enjoy them. Cameron says the soft edge “helps to lessen the tension many players encounter when putting.”

Who Makes Them?

Don T. “Scotty” Cameron is the founder of Scotty Cameron putters. Cameron started working on putters at the age of six with his father. By 12, he had created his owner putter using machinery from a friend’s dad. Mark O’ Meara was one of Cameron’s first notable professional client to use his putter when Cameron was only 22. 

A year later Cameron was hired by Ray Cook to design putters and was later hired by Mizuno. In 1994, 129 golfers on the PGA Tour used a Scotty Cameron putter at least one time. That same year, Cameron formed a partnership with Titleist.

Name Some Major Winners Who Use Them

Many of the world’s greatest golfers use Scotty Cameron Putters. Among those golfers, quite a few have won majors including Tiger Woods, Brooks Koepka, Justin Thomas, Gary Woodland, and Jordan Spieth.

Spotting a Fake Scotty Cameron Putter

When trying to identify a fake use the acronym: F.M.C.G. It stands for finish, material, craftsmanship and grip.

Finish: Look to see what the finish is supposed to look like on Scotty Cameron’s website and compare it to the item on sale.

Material: Counterfeiters use cheap metals such as zinc or aluminum rather than stainless steel. If you stick a magnet to the putter and it won’t stay on you know it’s fake.

Craftsmanship: On fakes the edges will be ultra-sharp and have wrong fonts on the texts as well as the weights could look a little loose or out of place.

Grip: A lot of fake Scotty Cameron putters will have replica grips that smell like burnt plastic.

Spotting A Fake Scotty Cameron

Are They Suitable For Beginners?

Scotty Cameron putters are suitable for golfers of all kinds of levels from novices to experts. That being said, a beginner who isn’t sure if they want to play golf for a long time probably shouldn’t purchase a Scotty Cameron due to the high price.

Are Scotty Cameron Putters Worth It?

With their mostly hefty price tag depending on the year and model, the only people who can truly determine if they are worth it are golfers themselves. 

If you’re thinking about buying a Scotty Cameron, head to the golf store and putt from different lengths with the Scotty Cameron comparing the results to your current putter and other putters on sale.   

Another thing you can do is work with your local club pro and get fitted for a putter. It’s important to get a customized putter for your game because certain golfers have different tendencies that might require a different loft, angle, weight or length.

Concluding Thoughts On The Best Scotty Cameron Putter

It’s hard to go wrong with any Scotty Cameron putter. The precision and high quality build makes them superior to many putters available to the public. That’s why they are used by the greatest golfers on the planet. After reviewing the different models our editor’s choice for the best Scotty Cameron putter is the Newport 2. With its Matador midsize grip and 303 stainless steel finish, the model is elite.

fAQ

Do Scotty Cameron putters hold their value?

Yes, Scotty Cameron putters do hold their value. The 303 stainless steel and technology packed putter is used by many professionals on tour including Justin Thomas and Jordan Spieth. You can sell a mint condition Scotty Cameron for close to retail price. 

Is a Scotty putter worth it?

Yes, Scotty Cameron putters are worth purchasing. The expensive materials used in creating the putter and the customization options help the putter mold to many different players’ styles. The swappable weight options help too. 

What putter is similar to Scotty Cameron?

There are multiple putters that perform similar to Scotty Cameron putters. The Ping Anser line has produced putters such as the PLD Milled Anser putter that rivals the Scotty Cameron. The club is made with 303 stainless steel and deep AMP faced milling. 

Photo of author

Author

Lawrence Smelser has been part of the Golfible writing staff since 2019 and is a freelance golf journalist. Smelser has covered the PGA Tour including the U.S. Masters with Augusta.com. He holds a journalism Bachelor’s degree from Texas A&M and a Master’s journalism degree from the University of North Texas. Learn more about our team at Golfible on our About Us page.

Leave a Comment